How to Choose an Affiliate Program: A 10-Point Checklist

How to Choose an Affiliate Program: A 10-Point Checklist
2 min.

Content

    To choose an affiliate program, compare five things: whether its offers fit your traffic and GEOs, how much you will actually earn per click (EPC), how and when it pays, how transparent its rules and reporting are, and what its reputation looks like. The headline payout on its own tells you very little: a high payout with low approval rates or late payments will earn less than an average payout from a reliable program.

    Below you’ll find a detailed checklist, red flags, questions to ask your affiliate manager and an example comparison of two programs.

    Types of affiliate programs

    TypeWhat it isProsCons
    In-house (direct) programThe brand’s own program: a casino, a store, a serviceOften higher payouts, direct contact with the productOffers from one brand only
    CPA / affiliate networkA platform with offers from many advertisersWide choice, one dashboard, consolidated payoutsThe network takes a cut
    Affiliate platformA service brands use to run their own programs (affiliate marketplaces)Easy discovery, standard trackingTerms vary by program

    Checklist: 10 criteria

    CriterionWhat to check
    1. Vertical and GEOAre there offers for your niche and the countries your traffic comes from?
    2. Allowed traffic sourcesIs your source accepted: SEO, social, search ads, push, incentivized traffic?
    3. Payout modelsCPA, CPL, RevShare, Hybrid — which are available, and can terms be negotiated?
    4. Payouts and EPCWhat is paid per action, and what do other affiliates earn per click on average?
    5. Hold periodHow many days between a conversion and its approval?
    6. PaymentsMinimum threshold, frequency and methods: card, bank transfer, crypto, payment systems
    7. Tracking and reportingReal-time stats, postbacks to your tracker, sub-ID breakdowns
    8. Approval and rulesWhat share of leads is approved, what gets traffic rejected, is there an approval guarantee?
    9. SupportIs there a dedicated manager, how fast do they reply, do they help with creatives and angles?
    10. ReputationReviews in industry chats and media, payment history, conference presence, licensed brands

    Why EPC matters more than the payout

    EPC (earnings per click) is the average revenue per click. It combines the payout, the conversion rate and the approval rate in one number.

    Example: program A pays $100 per deposit, but only 1 click in 200 becomes a paid deposit. Program B pays $60, but 1 click in 100 converts. EPC for A = $100 / 200 = $0.50; for B = $60 / 100 = $0.60. The program with the lower payout earns more.

    You only learn your real EPC by testing, so start with a small budget. Our guide to testing offers explains how to do it without wasting money.

    How to read hold and approval terms

    Advertisers use a hold period to filter out cancellations, fraud and bonus hunters. It usually lasts from a few days to a month. A long hold isn’t bad in itself, but it ties up your working capital. In iGaming, also check what counts as a qualifying first-time deposit (FTD) and the minimum deposit amount.

    Red flags

    • No clear rules. If it isn’t written down what gets traffic rejected, anything can be.
    • The program’s stats differ significantly from your tracker. Small gaps are normal; a consistent shortfall needs explaining. Under-reporting conversions is known as shaving.
    • Payments are regularly late, or payout terms change retroactively.
    • Payouts far above the market with no clear explanation.
    • Upfront fees or deposits required to access offers.
    • No information about the advertisers — or, in iGaming, about brand licences.
    • Bad reviews across several independent sources, not just one negative comment.

    Questions to ask your affiliate manager

    1. Which traffic sources and angles are allowed for this offer, and which aren’t?
    2. What approval rate and EPC do affiliates with similar traffic get?
    3. How long is the hold, and what exactly counts as a conversion?
    4. How often are payments made, what’s the minimum, and which methods are available?
    5. Can I get a custom payout after testing?
    6. Do you support postbacks and detailed sub-ID reporting?
    7. Which creatives and prelanders has the advertiser already approved?
    8. If the advertiser pauses the offer, how is traffic already sent paid out?

    Example: comparing two programs

    A hypothetical iGaming offer with Tier-2 traffic:

    ParameterProgram AProgram B
    CPA payout$100$80
    Minimum FTD amount$30$15
    Hold30 days7 days
    PaymentsMonthly, from $500Weekly, from $100
    PostbackNoYes
    Dedicated managerOnly for large volumesFrom day one

    For a beginner with a small budget, B is probably the better choice: a lower deposit threshold, faster cash flow and postbacks for optimization. Program A may become attractive later, once volumes grow and there is room to negotiate.

    How to vet a program before you start

    1. Read reviews in industry media and affiliate chats.
    2. Study the terms in the dashboard: traffic rules, hold, payments, restrictions.
    3. Talk to the manager using the questions above.
    4. Run a small test and reconcile the program’s stats with your own tracker.
    5. Wait for the first payment before scaling.

    We’ve collected affiliate program reviews with terms, GEOs and feedback in our affiliate program directory — a convenient place to start comparing.

    FAQ

    In-house program or affiliate network — which is better?

    Beginners usually find networks easier: many offers in one dashboard and consolidated payments. In-house programs pay off once you have a working setup and can deliver steady volume, which makes it easier to negotiate a higher payout.

    Can I work with several programs at once?

    Yes, and it’s standard practice. It reduces your risk if one program changes its terms or closes an offer.

    What is a normal hold period?

    It depends on the vertical. E-commerce and nutra holds are often short; iGaming and finance holds are longer because advertisers need time to assess customer quality. What matters is that the period is stated upfront and respected.

    What is shaving?

    It’s when a program underpays by under-reporting conversions or rejecting some without explanation. The defence is to reconcile stats with your own tracker and work with proven programs.

    How do I know a program is right for me?

    It accepts your traffic source and GEOs, its rules are clear, and your test showed an acceptable EPC and an on-time payment. Everything else is a bonus.

    New to the industry? Start with what affiliate marketing is and how it works.

    1to1agency.com